Project Runway - Brooke Shields, guest judge

The forum for general posting. Come join the madness. :)
Post Reply
Message
Author
User avatar
fuzzywuzzy
Posts: 533
Joined: Wed Oct 10, 2007 1:50 pm
Location: Jellystone National Park

Project Runway - Brooke Shields, guest judge

#1 Post by fuzzywuzzy » Thu Aug 14, 2008 7:25 am

Tim’s Take - Welcome to the Jungle

Heidi announces that for this challenge the twelve remaining designers will be designing for a high powered and glamorous professional woman. She tells them to meet me in the workroom where I will introduce them to their new client. The designers are wild with surprise and enthusiasm when Brooke Shields enters! She explains that they will be creating a day-to-evening outfit for her character on Lipstick Jungle, Wendy Healy. Wendy is an executive, a mother or two, and she's married to a musician. So, how does her wardrobe transition from the board room to a jazz club?
The designers have 30 minutes to sketch. Then, they will each pitch their concepts to Brooke who will choose six designers to serve as team leaders. The team leaders will select from the remaining six designers to form teams of two.

Each team has a budget of $150 and one day to complete the challenge. And each team must determine which team member's model will be used on the runway. Finally, Brooke will wear the winning look on this second season of Lipstick Jungle, and she will be our guest judge, of course!
Regarding the collaborative and synergistic dimensions within each team, there was rampant strife, consternation, and conflict. Designers, why is it so difficult to listen to each other, absorb content and meaning, and ... behave??

Keith wins! He chose Kenley as his teammate. Their conflict began at MOOD where Kenley acted as though she was the leader and bullied Keith to such an extent that I needed to step in and mediate. Her intractability coupled with her shrillness made her an exhausting opponent. Her cause célèbre was a floral print that she selected versus a floral print of Keith's. For me there was no contest: Keith's print was sophisticated and polished whereas Kenley's was Ma Kettle. I advised that they should purchase both of them, providing that their budget allowed, and debate this into resolution in the workroom. In the end, Keith won and, indeed, his design won. A high-waisted petal pencil skirt in diaphanous chocolate fabric served as a pedestal for the floral chiffon top. A wide black belt softened the transition between the two pieces. Owing to the high-end elegance of the look, I found it more difficult to see the day-to-evening transition, but the judges swooned and Brooke loved it. Congratulations, Keith! We'll see your design on Lipstick Jungle!

Kelli is out. She chose Daniel as her teammate. The lion's share of the fabric chosen was black. It was punctuated with leopard (Brooke had cautioned Kelli: "Watch the leopard!") and some odd blue fabric on the bustline that looked like a non sequitur. Daniel was assigned the construction of a black pencil skirt with ruching, but, owing to myriad mishaps, it took two-plus attempts to get it right. Kelli worked on a Kelli-esque bustier top that incorporated the leopard. The day-to-evening transition was offered through a shrunken jacket with a 360-degree peplum: It comes off at night. What was impossible to overcome was how cheap and tawdry the outfit looked, especially the bare midriff: Brooke's character would look like a hooker, not a power broker. Kelli, we will sincerely miss you!

Blayne is the team leader and chose Leanne. He conceived of a Bermuda shorts look, which by definition was going to be a day-to-evening challenge. From the onset, Brooke cited Blayne's shorts as being "risky," but she was interested in seeing if he could make them work. From my point of view, the success of this look was going to hinge on the textiles and palette. Therefore, the light gray fabric for the shorts and the baby-blue over-shirt were going to be obstacles. They were. This look couldn't transition beyond the casual tone set by the short or, god forefend, the bare midriff. Blayne, I'm merely happy that you're still with us!

Jerell is the team leader and is the last designer to select a teammate, so he is paired with the last designer standing, Stella. Jerell was in his prime, but Stella was thrown, once again, by the design context. Luckily, Jerell allowed her to stay within her comfort zone by giving her the assignment of the wide mustard leather ("lethuh") waistband with a smaller over-belt in zebra. This was over a full A-line skirt in a charcoal print and a dark taupe top with a sexy scooped neckline. Brooke loved the top and the skirt, but hated (her word) the waistband. Still, the look was sexy without being even remotely vulgar and it was tres chic.

Korto is the team leader and selected Joe. I didn't understand this look: a form-fitting strapless dress in taupe jersey under a voluminous and shapeless satin coat in pumpkin. What I am a firm believer in counterpoint, but why take the trouble of having a well-fitting dress only to obfuscate it with the big roomy top? There was considerable passive/aggressive behavior on this team, though Korto trumped Joe when she declared, "Well if this look loses, then I'm not going home, because I have immunity." Indeed. In the end, the coat was given some shape by belting it with a wide sash, and the look was safe, having passed through the judges' scrutiny. Whew!

Terri is the team leader and chose Suede. Oy! This was the clash of the titans! Terri assigned the top to Suede and gave herself the challenge(?) of the slim-fitting pant. That pant, in black, would serve as a mere pedestal to the top, which was the look's primary statement. Please don't misunderstand; I'm not trivializing the pant, because if the construction isn't perfect, then it could cause the look to go awry. But, it's still just a pant. The fashion statement was in the top, and Terri was going to ensure that Suede would execute her vision. This made it very difficult for Suede, because he was being micromanaged. The vibrant paisley gypsy top had a large cape, or berthe, neckline, a throwback to the 80's, but it looked modern and altogether appropriate. And it was true that the black pant was a fitting pedestal. The look had a sexy silhouette and great proportion and passed forward. Terri and Suede, when you reflect upon your behavior, was it really necessary?

Fuzzy’s take – I really thought Blayne should have gotten the heave ho! His design was NOT what Brooke requested, and it was terribly constructed…the crotch alone was hideous! I liked Keith’s design a lot, however, I really liked Jerell’s little ensemble. It was very hip, very chic, could work for day, and obviously could transition to evening quite well…However, I would have added a little bolero jacket or a cropped swing jacket for the day look. I think that would have really cinched it!

What did you think?

Ooh, next week should be really interesting when their assignment is to design a look for a drag queen! Can't wait! :wink:

fuzzy 8)
"Sometimes I wonder whether the world is being run by smart people who are putting us on or by imbeciles who really mean it."
— Mark Twain

"Be a first rate version of yourself, not a second rate version of someone else."
- Judy Garland

User avatar
Catfish
Posts: 2250
Joined: Mon Oct 08, 2007 12:58 pm
Location: Hoosier

Re: Project Runway - Brooke Shields, guest judge

#2 Post by Catfish » Thu Aug 14, 2008 8:00 am

fuzzywuzzy wrote:Ooh, next week should be really interesting when their assignment is to design a look for a drag queen! Can't wait! :wink:
I'm just glad to see Chris coming back. He's my PR fave.
Catfish

User avatar
5LD
Posts: 493
Joined: Mon Oct 08, 2007 11:52 am

#3 Post by 5LD » Thu Aug 14, 2008 8:49 am

I can't believe they auf'ed Kelly! I thought she was much much better than Blaine - all weeks taken into consideration.

I couldn't imagine that her dress was more offensive than his weekly inability to be on topic with his designs and his attempts to be the new "fierce" with his "Holla at yer boy".
"Tricks and treachery are the practice of fools, that don't have brains enough to be honest."
Ben Franklin

User avatar
Hotseat Or Bust!
Bored Hottie
Posts: 1593
Joined: Fri May 16, 2008 5:47 pm
Location: The Nutmeg State aka The Constitution State

#4 Post by Hotseat Or Bust! » Thu Aug 14, 2008 10:21 am

I was a bit distracted by Jerell's get-up and Leanne's dickey, but actually liked Terri and Suede's design the most.I thought it would be Daniel going home instead of Kelli. I too, am looking forward to seeing Chris on next week's episode!

User avatar
ulysses5019
Purveyor of Avatars
Posts: 19442
Joined: Mon Oct 08, 2007 10:52 am
Location: Los Angeles, CA

#5 Post by ulysses5019 » Thu Aug 14, 2008 11:13 am

Hotseat Or Bust! wrote:I was a bit distracted by Jerell's get-up and Leanne's dickey, but actually liked Terri and Suede's design the most.I thought it would be Daniel going home instead of Kelli. I too, am looking forward to seeing Chris on next week's episode!

You got a problem with dickeys?
I believe in the usefulness of useless information.

User avatar
Hotseat Or Bust!
Bored Hottie
Posts: 1593
Joined: Fri May 16, 2008 5:47 pm
Location: The Nutmeg State aka The Constitution State

#6 Post by Hotseat Or Bust! » Thu Aug 14, 2008 2:53 pm

ulysses5019 wrote:
Hotseat Or Bust! wrote:I was a bit distracted by Jerell's get-up and Leanne's dickey, but actually liked Terri and Suede's design the most.I thought it would be Daniel going home instead of Kelli. I too, am looking forward to seeing Chris on next week's episode!

You got a problem with dickeys?
Just the one Leanne was wearing in last night's episode.I'm sure your impeccably-dressed squirrel would agree!

User avatar
Hotseat Or Bust!
Bored Hottie
Posts: 1593
Joined: Fri May 16, 2008 5:47 pm
Location: The Nutmeg State aka The Constitution State

#7 Post by Hotseat Or Bust! » Thu Aug 14, 2008 2:59 pm

[quote="Hotseat Or Bust!"]I was a bit distracted by Jerell's get-up and Leanne's dickey, Not their designs, but the clothing that they themselves chose to wear during the runway show.

Post Reply