Bob Juch wrote:TheCalvinator24 wrote:Bob Juch wrote:
Well, I guess you had to be there to really know.
You just can't admit you're wrong, can you?
Nope.
At any rate, the question should have read: "One of his teachers" instead of implying he was the only one.[/quote from Bob J]
[This next part is me; I have not figured out how to 'quote' someone and then respond so that you can tell what is the 'quote' and what is the response]
I have several biographies of Beethoven, and they all make mention of Salieri: they describe him as being very willing to help new/rising composers.
The original question on WWTBAM was more tricky: it was Mike Munz's $1,000,000 question, and it did not ask who was Beethoven's teacher, but rather, stated that 'Beethoven was a student of which of the following composers?' and that is tricky because it is possible to be a 'student' of someone who is not actually your teacher-- I could be a 'student' of Beethoven, even though he died over a hundred years before I was born. When I saw that question, one of the thoughts that came to mind was that, on his deathbed, Beethoven spent his time reading Handel's scores, and he did 'study' them intensely (he believed that Handel was the greatest composer of all), and if I had been given that question I would have asked for clarification, did they mean 'student' in the sense of a 'student/teacher relationship' or did they mean 'student' in the sense of one who studies someone else's work.