kusch wrote:Not so good in the Instant Matchpoint game--54% good for 3rd.
Thoughts on this deal?
Dlr-S
Vul-none
I am south and dealt this:
AJ7
KQ9
Txxx
Axx
1D-X-1H-P
P-P
Ok, I know my partner cannot have 10pts or he would redouble.
That's not a good treatment. The problem is that if partner
has to redouble to show a good hand, you'll find yourself getting pre-empted. For example, suppose the auction goes 1D-X-XX-3S? You have no idea whether partner has 4, 5, or 6 hearts, 4, 5, or 6 clubs, or just a good balanced hand with interest in penalizing something.
Generally, you should save the redouble for hands that are relatively balanced and therefore more likely to want to sit a penalty double. One-level responses after a takeout double should not deny a good hand.
kusch wrote:I just took a view--actually I figured LHO would bid again and my pass was to leave options to my partner.
Partner held:
xx
J865
A
JT9752
Partner makes three hearts and we get 93 matchpoints on the hand.
Most N-S played in 1N or 2 or 3C--1N earns 29 matchpoints and 3C earns 69.
I suspect that good defense holds you to 110, or maybe even 80, which will likely be beaten by plus 90 or plus 120. In short, I suspect that your good result was not due to your bidding, but to getting a better-than-expected result in the contract you landed in.
If they figure out early to attack diamonds, how well does the hand play? If hearts are 4-2 (not unlikely under ordinary circumstances, and still more likely given the takeout double), then declarer can't handle even one tap before losing control.
kusch wrote:Then this slam we get to.
Dlr-N
Vul-E/W
I hold:
A752
AJ76
A862
x
Bidding goes:
1C-P-1D-P
1S-P-2H* 4th suit force-P
2N-P-3S-P
4N-P-5D--3KC-P
6S-passout
Partner hand:
KQ43
KT8
J
AQ942
He gets the KD lead and does not guess hearts right for down 1. Earn a fine 13 matchpoints. Not a great slam to be in but can be made. No one else bid slam--most were in 4S.
E hand
J98
Q9
KQT
KTxxx
We've all been in worse slams, but I'd want to be in game. I don't think partner's hand is good enough to jump to Blackwood on this auction. I'd settle for a 4C cue-bid, and then sign off. If slam is a good proposition, partner's going to have to hold enough to bid over my sign-off. With your hand, I'd probably make one try past game, but not two. I like the three aces, but I don't like the 4441 shape. As will become apparent, dealing with the fourth card in a suit is often a pain.
Having said that, assuming that spades broke, he should have brought the slam home. He needs to try real hard to avoid having to ruff dummy's fourth heart because he already needs to trump two of dummy's diamonds. The best play to accomplish this goal is the heart king followed by a
low heart to the jack. It pays off on precisely this layout -- because the queen comes down doubleton, you will take your four heart tricks with the king, ace, ten, and jack (in that order). You trump two diamonds, draw trump, and claim, losing a diamond at the end. Unfortunately, if you play it that way, you'll have trouble drawing the last trump.
Timing is a little tight. Best is to ruff a diamond immediately, take the heart hook (if it loses or if hearts don't break, you have the club hook in reserve to pitch the board's last diamond, with possible squeeze chances as well), ruff a second diamond and cash two trump. Then you have a decision to make. If you ruff a club to draw the last trump (pitching a club from hand), you won't be able to untangle the hearts. Fortunately, the fall of the 9 on the first round of the suit simplifies matters, if you trust it. Ruff a club to the board to draw the last trump, cross the the king of hearts, and when the queen falls, overtake the 10 with the ace to cash the 7. The 13th trick is a diamond, which you'll lose. --Bob