What danielh has been up to...
Posted: Wed Jan 30, 2008 10:54 am
Perhaps if it were an ad for a fresh produce company and depicted a bunch of young black kids looking at a large display of watermelons with their mouths watering you would say "Poor blacks, no sense of humor"?peacock2121 wrote:Poor catholics.
No sense of humor.
I was more wondering if they require nuns and other women not to look up when going through the Sistine Chapel. Or to avert their eyes when passing by the "David" statue.BackInTex wrote:Perhaps if it were an ad for a fresh produce company and depicted a bunch of young black kids looking at a large display of watermelons with their mouths watering you would say "Poor blacks, no sense of humor"?peacock2121 wrote:Poor catholics.
No sense of humor.
Really not a good analogy. Stereotypes have black people like/jones for watermelons. Stereotypes have nuns not like/jones for naked men.BackInTex wrote:Perhaps if it were an ad for a fresh produce company and depicted a bunch of young black kids looking at a large display of watermelons with their mouths watering you would say "Poor blacks, no sense of humor"?peacock2121 wrote:Poor catholics.
No sense of humor.
Yeah, I didn't get this analogy either. I'm glad I'm not the only one...peacock2121 wrote:Really not a good analogy. Stereotypes have black people like/jones for watermelons. Stereotypes have nuns not like/jones for naked men.BackInTex wrote:Perhaps if it were an ad for a fresh produce company and depicted a bunch of young black kids looking at a large display of watermelons with their mouths watering you would say "Poor blacks, no sense of humor"?peacock2121 wrote:Poor catholics.
No sense of humor.
Come up with a good analogy and I will be happy to answer your question.
Reminds me of back at one of my first jobs. Short, cute lady worked in my group. Got asked out by one of the unattached guys, and they went on a date or two. He was mortified when she left about six months later to become a nun. "I dated a NUN???"danielh41 wrote:And when I said that I've never modeled for nuns, I should probably amend that to "I've never knowingly modeled for nuns."
Ever-so-tactful me would've responded, "No, you turned her into one."gsabc wrote:Reminds me of back at one of my first jobs. Short, cute lady worked in my group. Got asked out by one of the unattached guys, and they went on a date or two. He was mortified when she left about six months later to become a nun. "I dated a NUN???"danielh41 wrote:And when I said that I've never modeled for nuns, I should probably amend that to "I've never knowingly modeled for nuns."
It is a good analogy. Humor was based on a stereotype. The difference being that blacks/watermelon is not necessarily a negative stereotype as there is nothing negative, immoral, perverted, or prudish about liking watermelon. The stereotype with Catholic Nuns, in this instance is slightly negative (not that is matters for my analogy) from the sponsors perspective because the sponsor likely feels the prudish (stereotypical) nature of nuns as foolish.peacock2121 wrote:Really not a good analogy. Stereotypes have black people like/jones for watermelons. Stereotypes have nuns not like/jones for naked men.BackInTex wrote:Perhaps if it were an ad for a fresh produce company and depicted a bunch of young black kids looking at a large display of watermelons with their mouths watering you would say "Poor blacks, no sense of humor"?peacock2121 wrote:Poor catholics.
No sense of humor.
Come up with a good analogy and I will be happy to answer your question.
Not sure about the black thing.BackInTex wrote:It is a good analogy. Humor was based on a stereotype. The difference being that blacks/watermelon is not necessarily a negative stereotype as there is nothing negative, immoral, perverted, or prudish about liking watermelon. The stereotype with Catholic Nuns, in this instance is slightly negative (not that is matters for my analogy) from the sponsors perspective because the sponsor likely feels the prudish (stereotypical) nature of nuns as foolish.peacock2121 wrote:Really not a good analogy. Stereotypes have black people like/jones for watermelons. Stereotypes have nuns not like/jones for naked men.BackInTex wrote: Perhaps if it were an ad for a fresh produce company and depicted a bunch of young black kids looking at a large display of watermelons with their mouths watering you would say "Poor blacks, no sense of humor"?
Come up with a good analogy and I will be happy to answer your question.
Yet unless the analogy it +/+ or -/- it can't work for you? My point, and one that I had hoped would be clear, is that people can be offended by stereotypes whether that stereotype is their behavior, looks, likes or dislikes.
Many blacks would certainly be offended by a watermelon analogy just as these Catholics are offended by the nude men analogy.
However, I do agree with your first point, no sense of humor. Just wonder if you'd say the same about other stereotypes.
LOL -- My cousin Patty dated a priest (before he was a priest.) He later married her!mrkelley23 wrote:Ever-so-tactful me would've responded, "No, you turned her into one."gsabc wrote:Reminds me of back at one of my first jobs. Short, cute lady worked in my group. Got asked out by one of the unattached guys, and they went on a date or two. He was mortified when she left about six months later to become a nun. "I dated a NUN???"danielh41 wrote:And when I said that I've never modeled for nuns, I should probably amend that to "I've never knowingly modeled for nuns."
In that case then... Yeah, that's me modeling...tlynn78 wrote:Nuns or no nuns, that model has a nice
uh, muscle tone. Yup, gooood muscle tone.
t.
In that case then... Yeah, that's me modeling...