Page 1 of 1

A hmmmm moment

Posted: Tue Nov 25, 2008 10:59 pm
by a1mamacat
watched a "Charlie Brown Thanksgiving" tonight.

The end of the show has Snoopy and Woodstock chowing down on the Turkey.

Seemed a little cannibalistic of Woodstock, to me

Re: A hmmmm moment

Posted: Wed Nov 26, 2008 3:21 am
by ulysses5019
a1mamacat wrote:watched a "Charlie Brown Thanksgiving" tonight.

The end of the show has Snoopy and Woodstock chowing down on the Turkey.

Seemed a little cannibalistic of Woodstock, to me
Maybe it was tofu turkey.

Re: A hmmmm moment

Posted: Wed Nov 26, 2008 7:10 am
by peacock2121
a1mamacat wrote:watched a "Charlie Brown Thanksgiving" tonight.

The end of the show has Snoopy and Woodstock chowing down on the Turkey.

Seemed a little cannibalistic of Woodstock, to me
I love it when people's internal thoughts get put on external.

Re: A hmmmm moment

Posted: Wed Nov 26, 2008 7:46 am
by Charlie Brown's Teacher
a1mamacat wrote:watched a "Charlie Brown Thanksgiving" tonight.

The end of the show has Snoopy and Woodstock chowing down on the Turkey.

Seemed a little cannibalistic of Woodstock, to me

Wah wah waaah wah wahwah, waaah... wah wah waaaaah!

Re: A hmmmm moment

Posted: Wed Nov 26, 2008 8:12 am
by gsabc
Birds eat other birds all the time. Our local paper had a photo of a hawk which had caught and was eating a pigeon right in view of the photographer, who grabbed the opportunity to capture nature in action.

Woodstock's a lot cuter than any turkey.

Re: A hmmmm moment

Posted: Wed Nov 26, 2008 8:13 am
by earendel
Charlie Brown's Teacher wrote:
a1mamacat wrote:watched a "Charlie Brown Thanksgiving" tonight.

The end of the show has Snoopy and Woodstock chowing down on the Turkey.

Seemed a little cannibalistic of Woodstock, to me

Wah wah waaah wah wahwah, waaah... wah wah waaaaah!
Excuse me, but I believe the parade is over there [pointing]. Check with The Parade Coordinator to find out where your spot is.

Re: A hmmmm moment

Posted: Wed Nov 26, 2008 12:30 pm
by andrewjackson
It is a good question, though.

How close does the taxonomic relationship have to be to consider it cannibalism?

I guess the strict definition is eating a member of the same species.

Do we know what species Woodstock is?

Snoopy once guessed crow, American bittern, Caroline wren, rufous-sided towhee, yellow-billed cuckoo, Canada goose, warbler, and a mourning warbler. And made a joke about Woodstock being a duck. None of those were correct.

I'm pretty sure that Woodstock is not in the same family or genus as the domestic turkey but he could be in the order Galliformes, with some of the other game birds.

Re: A hmmmm moment

Posted: Wed Nov 26, 2008 1:11 pm
by peacock2121
andrewjackson wrote:It is a good question, though.

How close does the taxonomic relationship have to be to consider it cannibalism?

I guess the strict definition is eating a member of the same species.

Do we know what species Woodstock is?

Snoopy once guessed crow, American bittern, Caroline wren, rufous-sided towhee, yellow-billed cuckoo, Canada goose, warbler, and a mourning warbler. And made a joke about Woodstock being a duck. None of those were correct.

I'm pretty sure that Woodstock is not in the same family or genus as the domestic turkey but he could be in the order Galliformes, with some of the other game birds.
aj is just plain adorable.

Re: A hmmmm moment

Posted: Wed Nov 26, 2008 3:56 pm
by franktangredi
a1mamacat wrote:watched a "Charlie Brown Thanksgiving" tonight.

The end of the show has Snoopy and Woodstock chowing down on the Turkey.

Seemed a little cannibalistic of Woodstock, to me
No more than us eating a hamburger. Birds eating birds ... mammals eating mammals.

Re: A hmmmm moment

Posted: Wed Nov 26, 2008 4:02 pm
by a1mamacat
franktangredi wrote:
a1mamacat wrote:watched a "Charlie Brown Thanksgiving" tonight.

The end of the show has Snoopy and Woodstock chowing down on the Turkey.

Seemed a little cannibalistic of Woodstock, to me
No more than us eating a hamburger. Birds eating birds ... mammals eating mammals.

Eeeeuwwwww, where do you get your meat???

remind me not to go to any of Frank's BBQ's

Re: A hmmmm moment

Posted: Wed Nov 26, 2008 4:49 pm
by andrewjackson
a1mamacat wrote:
franktangredi wrote:
a1mamacat wrote:watched a "Charlie Brown Thanksgiving" tonight.

The end of the show has Snoopy and Woodstock chowing down on the Turkey.

Seemed a little cannibalistic of Woodstock, to me
No more than us eating a hamburger. Birds eating birds ... mammals eating mammals.

Eeeeuwwwww, where do you get your meat???

remind me not to go to any of Frank's BBQ's
You don't eat mammals?

Some mammals are quite tasty.

Re: A hmmmm moment

Posted: Wed Nov 26, 2008 4:53 pm
by a1mamacat
andrewjackson wrote:
a1mamacat wrote:
franktangredi wrote: No more than us eating a hamburger. Birds eating birds ... mammals eating mammals.

Eeeeuwwwww, where do you get your meat???

remind me not to go to any of Frank's BBQ's
You don't eat mammals?

Some mammals are quite tasty.
I must be slipping. I pictured Frank's patties being Pattys :shock: