taanstafl2 says:
I would much rather have seen Journeyman get a longer shot at finding an audience but I guess that show was too cerebral, at least by TV standards, to have any shot. This one, not so much. The premise about the shaman giving him eternal youth until the "one true love" wanders by seems forced at best.
I will continue to watch for now but it I can perhaps see why it kept getting put back on the shelf. If it doesn't generate a solid following quickly I expect they will burn off the episodes they have in the can and then this one will join Journeyman in the TV show dumpster.
I agree with all of the above, especially about Journeyman; I knew from the start that the average TV audience person just wouldn't put up with all the literal jerking around, time-wise. Unless they were "really into it", & it took some getting into, at 1st, to warm up to the leads. Which was good
acting on their part but maybe bad TV. Other shows where people got jerked around in time, say Quantum Leap, they stayed in the "new time" (most of the time) until the problem they were "sent to solve" was solved (& that show had a hard time picking up an audience too, but it lasted several years nonetheless).
With Amsterdam: Its a smooth show, like Marley I like the "let's build NYC" intro, I agree the premise is wishy (I didn't even suss to the fact that he'd saved the shaman from his own evil fellows; I wondered why she appeared to be cursing him, actually; probably wasn't watching closely enough, & those flashbacks do provide "lose the audience" possibilities). But now that Journeyman is off forever & Moonlight for a while (someone read me a clip that now that the strike is off, new episodes had been ordered, so its still alive at least for this year, & prospects look good) the coast is apparently clear for more paranormal-show stuff.
I kind of like that we don't get superhuman feats of strength from this guy (other than that he appears to die but wakes up later) like we do from the reluctant vamp on Moonlight. Also, "no fangs" is good. Otherwise it'll be a police drama, with a bit of "I drank there in the 20s"/"I was deafened at Normandy" thrown in.