RIP Washoe
- earendel
- Posts: 13610
- Joined: Tue Oct 09, 2007 5:25 am
- Location: mired in the bureaucracy
RIP Washoe
The chimp who supposedly learned American Sign Language and used it in communicating with her handlers.
"Elen sila lumenn omentielvo...A star shines on the hour of our meeting."
- silvercamaro
- Dog's Best Friend
- Posts: 9608
- Joined: Mon Oct 08, 2007 11:45 am
Re: RIP Washoe
There was no "supposedly" about it. I knew Washoe, and I knew Dr. Roger Fouts, who was her guardian and protector when they were at the University of Oklahoma before they left for Washington. As a staff member in what then was the News Services Office, I wrote many news stories and features about them. The saddest day of that job was when I had to announce to the world that her baby, Sequoyah, had died. Science lost something that day, too, because everyone in the field wanted to find out if Washoe would teach sign language to her son, or if he would pick it up by observation of her with humans.earendel wrote:The chimp who supposedly learned American Sign Language and used it in communicating with her handlers.
Washoe's loudest detractor at that time probably was Noam Chomsky, who argued that the chimps who learned sign language were nothing more than primate versions of Hans the Wonder Horse, and figured out what reactions their handlers wanted through nonverbal and perhaps unconscious clues. Evidence that Washoe and others indeed understood how language operates included their combination of known words (signs) into meanings that described new things. For example, when Washoe was given watermelon for the first time, she had been taught no word, but promptly called it "water fruit." She called ducks, which she did not like, "dirty birds." "Dirty," it should be noted, was her word for excrement. And so on.
I witnessed exchanges between Dr. Fouts and Washoe that I cannot comprehend in any sense other than "conversation."
No matter what her species, Washoe was a great lady. I will grieve her passing, and I will send my personal condolences to Dr. Fouts.
- earendel
- Posts: 13610
- Joined: Tue Oct 09, 2007 5:25 am
- Location: mired in the bureaucracy
Re: RIP Washoe
I said "supposedly" because the AP article had this paragraph at the end:silvercamaro wrote:There was no "supposedly" about it. I knew Washoe, and I knew Dr. Roger Fouts, who was her guardian and protector when they were at the University of Oklahoma before they left for Washington. As a staff member in what then was the News Services Office, I wrote many news stories and features about them. The saddest day of that job was when I had to announce to the world that her baby, Sequoyah, had died. Science lost something that day, too, because everyone in the field wanted to find out if Washoe would teach sign language to her son, or if he would pick it up by observation of her with humans.earendel wrote:The chimp who supposedly learned American Sign Language and used it in communicating with her handlers.
Washoe's loudest detractor at that time probably was Noam Chomsky, who argued that the chimps who learned sign language were nothing more than primate versions of Hans the Wonder Horse, and figured out what reactions their handlers wanted through nonverbal and perhaps unconscious clues. Evidence that Washoe and others indeed understood how language operates included their combination of known words (signs) into meanings that described new things. For example, when Washoe was given watermelon for the first time, she had been taught no word, but promptly called it "water fruit." She called ducks, which she did not like, "dirty birds." "Dirty," it should be noted, was her word for excrement. And so on.
I witnessed exchanges between Dr. Fouts and Washoe that I cannot comprehend in any sense other than "conversation."
No matter what her species, Washoe was a great lady. I will grieve her passing, and I will send my personal condolences to Dr. Fouts.
But there was controversy over whether the chimp was really using ASL. Cognitive scientist Steven Pinker has contended that the notion that Washoe was the first non-human to acquire a human language was without scientific support."
No mention of Chomsky, although I recall at the time the debate over Washoe's abilities. I, for one, never doubted it, but there were detractors.
"Elen sila lumenn omentielvo...A star shines on the hour of our meeting."
- silvercamaro
- Dog's Best Friend
- Posts: 9608
- Joined: Mon Oct 08, 2007 11:45 am
Re: RIP Washoe
I'm not familiar with Pinker's work. Perhaps he was too young to have gained prominence during the time Washoe was here. He does seem to be a Chomsky disciple, if the entry on Wikipedia is accurate. If I read one of his books, I'll let you know what I think of his arguments. If he's merely saying that Washoe may not have been the first nonhuman to acquire human language, then he may theorize that earlier gabby nonhumans simply didn't have their linguistics skills documented. I dunno. I won't accept his theorizing over what I've witnessed without some pretty strong evidence and arguments to the contrary.earendel wrote: I said "supposedly" because the AP article had this paragraph at the end:
But there was controversy over whether the chimp was really using ASL. Cognitive scientist Steven Pinker has contended that the notion that Washoe was the first non-human to acquire a human language was without scientific support."
No mention of Chomsky, although I recall at the time the debate over Washoe's abilities. I, for one, never doubted it, but there were detractors.
- earendel
- Posts: 13610
- Joined: Tue Oct 09, 2007 5:25 am
- Location: mired in the bureaucracy
Re: RIP Washoe
I don't see any reason why it would be impossible for Washoe (or any other chimpanzee) to be taught ASL or to be able to demonstrate "cognitive" functions (such as putting together signs to form new words and concepts). I just wonder why no one has tried since - at least I'm not familiar with any such (aside from Koko the gorilla).silvercamaro wrote:I'm not familiar with Pinker's work. Perhaps he was too young to have gained prominence during the time Washoe was here. He does seem to be a Chomsky disciple, if the entry on Wikipedia is accurate. If I read one of his books, I'll let you know what I think of his arguments. If he's merely saying that Washoe may not have been the first nonhuman to acquire human language, then he may theorize that earlier gabby nonhumans simply didn't have their linguistics skills documented. I dunno. I won't accept his theorizing over what I've witnessed without some pretty strong evidence and arguments to the contrary.
"Elen sila lumenn omentielvo...A star shines on the hour of our meeting."
- silvercamaro
- Dog's Best Friend
- Posts: 9608
- Joined: Mon Oct 08, 2007 11:45 am
Re: RIP Washoe
It has been done many times since. Washoe and Koko got the most publicity, because they were the firsts for their respective species. While the primate lab was in operation at OU, at least a dozen -- and probably more like 15-20 -- chimpanzees were reasonably fluent in ASL. Younger researchers, on the whole, probably are more inclined to take their interests to areas that haven't yet been as thoroughly explored and that are less expensive (or have greater availability for grants.)earendel wrote:
I don't see any reason why it would be impossible for Washoe (or any other chimpanzee) to be taught ASL or to be able to demonstrate "cognitive" functions (such as putting together signs to form new words and concepts). I just wonder why no one has tried since - at least I'm not familiar with any such (aside from Koko the gorilla).
- earendel
- Posts: 13610
- Joined: Tue Oct 09, 2007 5:25 am
- Location: mired in the bureaucracy
Re: RIP Washoe
I wasn't aware that the primate lab had ceased operation at OU. Was it the result of funding issues or animal rights activists?silvercamaro wrote:It has been done many times since. Washoe and Koko got the most publicity, because they were the firsts for their respective species. While the primate lab was in operation at OU, at least a dozen -- and probably more like 15-20 -- chimpanzees were reasonably fluent in ASL. Younger researchers, on the whole, probably are more inclined to take their interests to areas that haven't yet been as thoroughly explored and that are less expensive (or have greater availability for grants.)
"Elen sila lumenn omentielvo...A star shines on the hour of our meeting."
- silvercamaro
- Dog's Best Friend
- Posts: 9608
- Joined: Mon Oct 08, 2007 11:45 am
Re: RIP Washoe
Funding, jealousy, and internal politics. Long story. Most sadly, although Fouts had a legal claim to Washoe, so he could take her with him, most of the other chimpanzees were sold to commercial research outfits for experimentation with drugs and disease, including AIDS. To me, this is a major black mark for a number of people who still live in this area. If I ran into some of them tomorrow, I might kick them in the shins -- but I'd be aiming higher.earendel wrote:
I wasn't aware that the primate lab had ceased operation at OU. Was it the result of funding issues or animal rights activists?
Oops. I just blew the Gandhi Award for 2008, too.
- MarleysGh0st
- Posts: 27934
- Joined: Mon Oct 08, 2007 10:55 am
- Location: Elsewhere
Re: RIP Washoe
At least Annie's still in the running.silvercamaro wrote:Oops. I just blew the Gandhi Award for 2008, too.
She's not that kind of girl!
![Smile :)](./images/smilies/icon_smile.gif)
- themanintheseersuckersuit
- Posts: 7619
- Joined: Mon Oct 08, 2007 6:37 pm
- Location: South Carolina
Re: RIP Washoe
I think Mr. Gandhi would understand and forgive you, your Irish high kick.silvercamaro wrote:
Oops. I just blew the Gandhi Award for 2008, too.
Suitguy is not bitter.
feels he represents the many educated and rational onlookers who believe that the hysterical denouncement of lay scepticism is both unwarranted and counter-productive
The problem, then, is that such calls do not address an opposition audience so much as they signal virtue. They talk past those who need convincing. They ignore actual facts and counterargument. And they are irreparably smug.
feels he represents the many educated and rational onlookers who believe that the hysterical denouncement of lay scepticism is both unwarranted and counter-productive
The problem, then, is that such calls do not address an opposition audience so much as they signal virtue. They talk past those who need convincing. They ignore actual facts and counterargument. And they are irreparably smug.
- earendel
- Posts: 13610
- Joined: Tue Oct 09, 2007 5:25 am
- Location: mired in the bureaucracy
Re: RIP Washoe
No, she wouldn't kick them - she'd lambaste them in an opera.MarleysGh0st wrote:At least Annie's still in the running.silvercamaro wrote:Oops. I just blew the Gandhi Award for 2008, too.
She's not that kind of girl!
"Elen sila lumenn omentielvo...A star shines on the hour of our meeting."
- Ritterskoop
- Posts: 5744
- Joined: Thu Oct 11, 2007 10:16 pm
- Location: Charlotte, NC
I remember reading about Koko, and how she grieved for someone close to her, so they gave her a kitten, whom she named All Ball.
That was a cognitive act.
That was a cognitive act.
If you fail to pilot your own ship, don't be surprised at what inappropriate port you find yourself docked. - Tom Robbins
--------
At the moment of commitment, the universe conspires to assist you. - attributed to Johann Wolfgang von Goethe.
--------
At the moment of commitment, the universe conspires to assist you. - attributed to Johann Wolfgang von Goethe.
- Bob Juch
- Posts: 26531
- Joined: Mon Oct 08, 2007 11:58 am
- Location: Oro Valley, Arizona
- Contact: